Skip to main content

The Sugar Cup by Annie Sims: A blend of romance, mystery, and heartfelt charm

What happens when an unexpected inheritance brings along more mysteries than memories?

In The Sugar Cup, Annie Sims spins a 92-page gem of romance and tangled pasts. Set against the backdrop of small-town life, it is a story that is as comforting as a warm mug on a chilly night. You will meet Liz, who’s just inherited a house, a suspiciously valuable sugar cup, and a slew of complicated problems—including her dashing yet equally problematic new neighbour, Jace McGuinn. It’s romance with a dose of mystery and unexpected twists that keeps you turning the pages. If you are a fan of contemporary romance that’s short but layered, The Sugar Cup is worth your time.

The Backstory: What’s the buzz about The Sugar Cup?

In The Sugar Cup, Annie Sims gives us Liz, a character who’s adopted a dog but is now inheriting a mountain of trouble. Alongside that is a neighbour she’s irresistibly drawn to, and a seemingly innocent sugar cup that carries far more intrigue than its name suggests. Liz's journey weaves romance with light suspense and the kind of warmth that only well-written, small-town stories can deliver.

To sweeten the pot, Sims brings her knack for cosy scenes and genuine emotional beats. Fans of Harlequin romance know they can count on the brand for stories with heart and charm, and The Sugar Cup delivers. 

Also Read: Love By Design by Nora Roberts - Book Review - An Omnibus of Romance, Laughter, and Longing

What makes The Sugar Cup uniquely charming?

Let us break down the ingredients that make The Sugar Cup such a nice read:

  1. Relatable Heroine
    Elizabeth isn’t your typical romance novel heroine. She is unassuming, grounded, and refreshingly authentic. Faced with an inheritance of unexpected wealth and one dubious sugar cup, she becomes entangled in the McGuinn family’s heated battle over the property. You’ll quickly find yourself rooting for Caroline—not just in love but in life.

  2. A Dash of Mystery
    Sims gives The Sugar Cup an edge by mixing in a few surprising elements of suspense. Why would someone contest her inheritance of the house? And what is the real story behind that mysterious sugar cup? Liz's seemingly quiet life takes a thrilling turn as these elements unfold.

  3. Opposites Attract
    Liz’s chemistry with Jace McGuinn is an exciting blend of attraction and tension. Jace, while frustrating, becomes an intriguing puzzle she can’t ignore. Despite their differences, they bring out the best in each other.

What’s a famous quote from the book?

Perhaps the book’s best-known line comes early on, 
"Life hands you lemons, they say. But what about a sugar cup full of secrets?"

Why does This romance Stand out?

Annie Sims’ storytelling style doesn’t rely on overwrought melodrama. Instead, her characters feel real—grounded in empathy, and just enough vulnerability. By making her protagonists deal with relatable struggles, Sims creates a romance that feels accessible even to non-romance readers. If you are looking for something refreshing in contemporary romance, this book may just be it.

Must Read - The Idol Thief by S. Vijay Kumar - Book Review

How does The Sugar Cup Compare to Recent Romance Novels?

If The Sugar Cup has charmed you, here are five new romance novels released in 2024 that share a similar allure:

  1. The Whispering Trees by Lila Stone
    Lila Stone’s novel tells a story of rediscovery in the countryside, where a woman returns to her family estate, only to meet a childhood friend-turned-enemy. It is a romance laced with nostalgia and family drama.

  2. Just One Second by Marina Chase
    This contemporary romance takes place in New York City, where fate intertwines the lives of two ambitious professionals during a single second. 

  3. Hearts Over Hummus by Asha Patel
    A romance with a twist of cultural nuance, Hearts Over Hummus is a feel-good novel about a chef and food blogger who bond over a cooking competition. It is for fans of light-hearted love stories.

  4. Against the Grain by Leo Torres
    Torres brings a fresh angle with a romance set in a woodworking shop. As two artisans clash over a shared project, sparks and sawdust fly in this slow-burn romance.

  5. Forever Interrupted by Callie Lee
    Lee’s latest novel revolves around a seemingly impossible love story between a couple who find each other after enduring personal tragedies. 

Is the story sweet enough for everyone?

While short, The Sugar Cup delivers on the promises of romance with a sweet, satisfying story that doesn’t feel rushed.  It is a weekend read that won’t overwhelm you but still leaves you with that warm glow every romance fan craves.

Is this the kind of book you’d recommend to a friend?

With just 92 pages, it is a story you can read in a single sitting—an excellent pick for those moments when you need a little escape.

Frequently asked Questions

What genre is The Sugar Cup?
The Sugar Cup is a contemporary romance with elements of mystery and suspense.

How long is the book?
The book is a short read with 92 pages, perfect for a cosy afternoon.

Who would enjoy this book?
Fans of romance, especially those who enjoy small-town settings and light mystery elements, will love The Sugar Cup.

Is The Sugar Cup part of a series?
No, this book is a standalone.

Can I find it in ebook format?
While it’s primarily available in paperback, some digital versions might exist on specific platforms.

___

If you are a fan of romance that is as charming as it is mysterious, The Sugar Cup should be on your list. Its short length makes it a quick, cosy read, yet Sims packs in enough intrigue to keep you guessing.

Tushar Mangl is an energy healer and writer who explores books, personal finance, and a greener society. Author of Hey Honey Bunch and The Avenging Act, Tushar believes in creating a balanced, fulfilling life.

Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Also read

Cutting people off isn’t strength—It is a trauma response

Your ability to cut people off and self-isolate is not a skill you should be proud of—It is a trauma response Cutting people off and self-isolating may feel like a protective shield, but it is often rooted in unresolved or unhealed trauma and an inability to depend on others. While these behaviors seem like self-preservation, they end up reinforcing isolation and blocking meaningful connections. Confronting these patterns, seeking therapy, and nurturing supportive relationships can help break this unhealthy cycle. Plus, a simple act like planting a jasmine plant can symbolise the start of your journey towards emotional healing. Why do we cut people off and isolate? If you’re someone who prides themselves on “cutting people off” or keeping a tight circle, you might believe it’s a skill—a way to protect yourself from betrayal, hurt, or unnecessary drama. I get it. I’ve been there, too. But here’s the thing: this ability to isolate yourself is not as empowering as it may seem. In fact, i...
Post a Comment
Read more

How to mourn a friend who didn’t die — Just disappeared

A reflective friendship day guide on ambiguous grief and ghosted goodbyes On this Friendship Day, we explore a grief that hides in plain sight — the sorrow of losing a friend who didn’t die but just faded away. This reflective, heart-first guide honours the ache of ambiguous grief, offers healing rituals, and gently walks you through mourning lost connections — without blame, guilt, or pressure to “move on.” Intro Letter: To the friend I lost without a funeral… Hey, It is Friendship Day today. Social media’s buzzing with throwbacks, inside jokes, emojis, and bestie declarations. And yet, here I am, thinking of you . Not because we celebrated Friendship Day together, but because we never got to say goodbye. You’re not gone in the conventional sense. No candlelight vigils. No condolences. You didn’t die. You just… disappeared. And the world tells me to “get over it.” But my heart keeps whispering, “We were *something.*” Maybe we faded. Maybe you ghosted. Maybe life got loud. But there ...
Post a Comment
Read more

The days you want to disappear: A no-shame survival guide (powered by positive peer pressure)

Ever whispered, “I just don’t want to be here”? You’re not alone—and you’re not broken. This grounded, no-shame guide offers tools for those crash days when disappearing feels like the only option. Learn how to cope gently, ask for help bravely, and rebuild a little light using positive peer pressure, real talk, and tiny acts of hope. First edition Published on 06/11/2009 23:26 Revised edition Published on 06/08/2025 18:52 The days you want to disappear: Coping without shaming yourself (with positive peer pressure) “You didn’t want to die. You just didn’t want to be here anymore.”   Some days don’t hurt in obvious ways. There’s no accident. No argument. No trigger you can point to. Just a dull, constant ache in your chest. A buzzing in your skull. A quiet hope that everyone forgets you exist for a while so you don’t have to explain what’s wrong. But something is wrong.And you can’t even name it without sounding ridiculous. So you say nothing. Or maybe you whisper somet...
Post a Comment
Read more